Thursday, March 05, 2026

Blue Moon - Review: A Bittersweet Farewell to a Broadway Legend

BLUE MOON (2025)

★★★½☆

"A Bittersweet Farewell to a Broadway Legend"

By Ray Manukay

Official Release
Oct 24, 2025
Rotten Tomatoes
89%
Letterboxd
3.8/5
Running Time
1h 40m

📝 Official Synopsis

On March 31, 1943, famed lyricist Lorenz Hart spends the opening night of his former partner’s new hit, Oklahoma!, at Sardi's bar. Haunted by his own fading genius and the rise of Rodgers & Hammerstein, Hart navigates a night of whiskey, wit, and crushing reality.

👥 Expanded Cast Profile

  • Ethan Hawke as Lorenz Hart
  • Andrew Scott as Richard Rodgers
  • Margaret Qualley as Elizabeth Weiland
  • Bobby Cannavale as Eddie
  • Simon Delaney as Oscar Hammerstein II
  • Cillian Sullivan as Stephen "Stevie" Sondheim
  • Patrick Kennedy as E.B. "Andy" White

🎬 Expanded Crew Profile

  • Director: Richard Linklater 
  • Screenwriter: Robert Kaplow 
  • Producers: Mike Blizzard, John Sloss, Richard Linklater 
  • Cinematographer: Shane F. Kelly 
  • Film Editor: Sandra Adair
  • Composer: Graham Reynolds 

🏰 Industrial & Production Brief

Distributed globally by Sony Pictures Classics, Blue Moon represents a highly anticipated 12-year creative development cycle between director Richard Linklater and star Ethan Hawke. Linklater intentionally delayed production for over a decade until Hawke reached the exact biological age required to convincingly inhabit the physical and emotional weariness of Broadway lyricist Lorenz Hart. The project adapts a screenplay written by Robert Kaplow, mapping an meticulously contained timeline that unfolds entirely over a single night within a smoky New York bar on March 31, 1943, juxtaposing Hart's personal downward spiral against the massive opening-night success of his former partner's landmark musical, Oklahoma!

🎭 Where You've Seen Them Before

Ethan Hawke (Lorenz Hart)
  • Before Trilogy
  • First Reformed
Andrew Scott (Richard Rodgers)
  • Ripley
  • Sherlock

The Official Trailer

Ray's Review
"Blue Moon is a real-time drama that with its dialogue heavy script and single location setting resembles a filmed stage play more than a traditional cinematic film. This is not a criticism of Richard Linklater, who does a strong job of keeping the action flowing even among lengthy speeches but rather, it is simply the nature of a story that demands a static presentation.

The film is anchored by a powerhouse performance from Ethan Hawke as Lorenz Hart. It is a showcase that captures the tragic self-destruction of a man unable to overcome his demons in a world eager to pass him by. Andrew Scott also stands out as his longtime writing partner, Richard Rodgers. Rodgers feels a deep responsibility and loyalty toward his colleague but has grown weary of enabling Hart’s self-destructive behavior. Throughout the film, he slowly confirms to himself that the only choice is to walk away before he, too, is dragged down into the darkness.

Hawke dominates the film with long monologues that may initially come off as blustering. However, between these insecurity-tinged speeches, we feel the pain of a man who must keep talking to avoid the crushing reality of silence. It is a desperation that feels grating at first, until the inherent sadness underneath his shame and lack of self-esteem is revealed.

Bobby Cannavale is also a standout as a charming bartender who mercifully lends Hart an ear without judgment, while Margaret Qualley plays an ingenue whose stunning, innocent beauty represents a romantic ideal that remains hopelessly unattainable for Hart.

Ultimately, while Blue Moon is an entertaining film, it lacks the driving force necessary to make the plot truly memorable, despite the stellar work by Hawke. Watch the film to appreciate the acting prowess on display. Skip if looking for a film with strong, gripping action or a propulsive plot with dynamic locations."

⚖️ Pros & Cons

PROS:
  • Award-worthy turns by Hawke and Scott.
  • Brilliant, witty script by Robert Kaplow.
CONS:
  • Static framing approach may feel slow for action-focused viewers.
🏆 Final Verdict
Blue Moon Movie Poster

FINAL VERDICT: ★★★☆

A beautifully acted character study that Broadway buffs will adore, even if it feels a bit boxed-in.

💡 Cinephile Fun Facts

  • The 12-Year Biological Wait: Ethan Hawke read the script a decade before filming, but director Richard Linklater intentionally shelved the project for years so Hawke could age into the exact physical and emotional weariness required for Lorenz Hart without relying on prosthetics or artificial makeup .
  • Robbed of Vanity: To accurately mimic the 5'2" stature and appearance of the legendary lyricist, Hawke had to shed his vanity entirely—wearing dark brown contact lenses, walking with a pronounced physical stoop, and partially shaving his head to style a real, unflattering combover .
  • A Lightning-Fast 15 Days: Despite its complex dramatic weight and dense monologue work, the entire feature film was shot over a remarkably swift 15-day schedule on a controlled soundstage in Dublin, Ireland .
  • Literary Easter Eggs: The script contains hidden nods where Hart unknowingly inspires historical icons. In one scene, he tells a visiting E.B. White about a friendly mouse in his apartment that he named "Stuart"—inspiring White to publish Stuart Little two years later in 1945.
  • Sardi's Blessing: To capture the exact atmospheric weight of the iconic Theater District bar where the movie takes place, co-stars Ethan Hawke and Bobby Cannavale stopped by the real Sardi's in New York City for a drink together right before catching their flight to the filming location .
poster