Emilia Pérez 2024 - Review: An operatic stylized musical journey

Emilia Pérez

An Innovative and Operatic Musical Drama

★★★☆☆

A highly stylized affair that boldly challenges conventions and breaks new ground in the genre.

Directed by Jacques Audiard, Emilia Pérez is an operatic journey that navigates the unlikely intersection of Mexican drug cartels and gender affirmation. Zoe Saldaña delivers a standout performance as an ambitious lawyer caught in the orbit of a cartel leader seeking a new life. This is a film that demands a high degree of "buy-in" from the audience, leaning heavily into its heightened, stylized reality and Spanish-language musical numbers.

"The film should be viewed as a cinematic opera... the performances and situations are bigger than life, and shouldn't be viewed as dramatically realistic."

— Ray Manukay

🎬 Production Brief

• Director: Jacques Audiard
• Starring: Zoe Saldaña, Karla Sofía Gascón, Selena Gomez
• Language: Spanish
• Genre: Musical / Crime Drama / Comedy

Visceral Style Over Melodic Hook

Audiard deserves appreciation for the visceral energy and distinctive style displayed throughout the runtime. The film features eccentric musical numbers with undeniable visual flair, though the songs themselves lack melodic catchiness and the singing voices are not particularly memorable. While it avoids being an authentic representation of Mexican culture, it succeeds as a storybook backdrop for over-the-top drama and surprising comedic moments.

💡 Cinephile Fun Facts

• Cannes History: The entire female ensemble (Gascón, Saldaña, Gomez, and Adriana Paz) collectively won the Best Actress award at the 2024 Cannes Film Festival.
• Historic Lead: Karla Sofía Gascón became the first openly trans actor to win a major award at Cannes for her portrayal of the title character.
• French Connection: Despite the setting and language, the film was largely shot on soundstages in Paris, emphasizing its "operatic" and artificial nature.

✅ Pros

• Strong, award-winning ensemble performances led by Zoe Saldaña.
• Innovative, genre-defying premise that breaks new ground.
• Distinctive visual flair and high visceral energy.

❌ Cons

• Musical numbers lack melodic "hooks" and are not very memorable.
• Cultural representation is arguably superficial or "storybook."
• Highly stylized tone may alienate viewers seeking realism.

The Full Analysis

Emilia Pérez is an innovative and operatic musical drama that boldly challenges conventions, setting out to break new ground within the genre. The film features strong performances from its entire ensemble cast, but Zoe Saldaña stands out as an ambitious lawyer navigating the dangerous world of Mexican drug cartels. She finds herself helping a powerful drug lord rebuild their life after undergoing a sex change, a premise that ensures this musical is a highly stylized affair.

One’s enjoyment of the film likely depends on a willingness to accept these heightened conventions and the unique premise, not to mention the extensive singing and dancing in Spanish. Critics have argued that the film is not an authentic representation of Mexican culture, which is a fair point considering the limited participation of Mexican performers and director Jacques Audiard’s French descent. However, the film should perhaps be viewed as a cinematic opera, with its unflattering portrayal of Mexico serving as a storybook backdrop for heightened drama.

The performances and situations are larger than life and should not be viewed through a lens of dramatic realism. There is also a level of comedy to be found in these over-the-top scenarios. Director Jacques Audiard deserves appreciation for the visceral energy and distinctive style he brings to the screen. The movie features several eccentric musical numbers with entertaining visual flair, though it must be noted that the music and singing voices are not particularly memorable, and the songs themselves are not melodically catchy.

While I would personally stop short of calling Emilia Pérez a masterpiece or one of the absolute best films of the year, it remains a notable and interesting work of 2024. It will be fascinating to see how time treats this project, and whether it will age gracefully as a bold experiment or be eventually forgotten as a unique curio of its time. Regardless, it stands as a powerfully invigorated piece of filmmaking that demands attention for its sheer ambition.

🏆 Final Verdict

A notable and unique curio of 2024. While I stop short of calling it a "great" movie, Emilia Pérez is an undeniable cinematic experiment that earns kudos for its bravery and style. Only time will tell if it becomes a classic or a forgotten novelty.

View on Letterboxd