Saturday, February 28, 2026

Marty Supreme - Review: A STYLISH SHOWCASE LACKING SINCERE HEART

Original Release Date
December 25, 2025
Rotten Tomatoes
93%
Letterboxd Score
3.9/5
Running Time
2h 30m

Official Synopsis

Set against the vibrant and competitive world of mid-century table tennis, Marty Supreme is a fast-paced, stylized drama loosely inspired by the life of professional ping-pong champion Marty Reisman. Navigating the subcultures of 1950s New York City, the film chronicles the meteoric rise, eccentricities, and hustler mentality of a sporting icon. Josh Safdie delivers a highly energetic, vintage character piece tracking the cost of obsession, showmanship, and absolute dominance over a miniature green table.




The Ensemble Lineup

Complete on-screen roster verified from production archives:

  • Timothée Chalamet as Marty Reisman
  • Gwyneth Paltrow as Kay Stone
  • Tyler, the Creator as Wally
  • Fran Drescher as Marty’s Mother
  • Odessa A’zion as Rachel Mizler
  • Penn Jillette as Hoff
  • Kevin O'Leary as Milton Rockwell
  • Sandra Bernhard as Judy
  • Abel Ferrara as Ezra Mishkin
  • Hailey Gates as Trish

The Off-Screen Architects

Behind-the-camera production assembly:

  • Director: Josh Safdie
  • Writers: Josh Safdie & Ronald Bronstein
  • Producers: Eli Bush, Anthony Katagas, Ronald Bronstein, Josh Safdie, Timothée Chalamet
  • Cinematographer: Darius Khondji
  • Costume Designer: Miyako Bellizzi
  • Production Designer: Mark Friedberg

Film Specifications & Production Info

Principal Photography September 2024 – December 2024
Primary Backing Studio A24 Films
Capture Format 35mm Film (High-Contrast Chemical Emulsion)
Filming Locations New York City, New York (Manhattan & Outer Boroughs)
Narrative Focus Mid-Century Sports Culture / Professional Table Tennis Drama






 Production Vault: Internal Records

  • Solo Venture Transition: This title goes down in the ledger as Josh Safdie’s definitive debut as a solo feature-length fiction director since his early career, operating entirely independent of the established "Safdie Brothers" moniker.
  • Thematic Source Material: The script’s foundation is openly constructed around the cultural trajectory of iconic American ping-pong champion Marty Reisman, adapting the raw aesthetic of Madison Square Garden's 1950s gambling subcultures.
  • Auteur Cross-Pollination: Acclaimed underground filmmaker Abel Ferrara was integrated directly onto the physical canvas in a performance role, cementing the film's New York cinephile street-cred.
  • Cross-Media Crossovers: The project marks the highly publicized dramatic acting debut of Tyler, the Creator, whose involvement shifted the film's macro-hype profile immediately during tracking phases.
Where You've Seen Them
TIMOTHÉE CHALAMET
  • Dune (Paul Atreides)
  • Wonka
  • Call Me by Your Name
JOSH SAFDIE (Director)
  • Uncut Gems
  • Good Time
  • Heaven Knows What
"Marty Supreme is mostly just a premiere performance display for Timothée Chalamet and a directing showcase for Josh Safdie." - Ray Manukay
Production Info
Director: Josh Safdie
Lead: Timothée Chalamet
Setting: 1950s USA
Genre: Character Study / Comedy

Official Trailer



Cinephile Fun Facts
  • Return of the A24 Darling: This marks Chalamet's return to A24, the studio that helped launch him with Lady Bird.
  • Solo Safdie: This is one of the first major solo directing efforts for Josh Safdie without his brother, Benny.
  • Sports Metaphor: The film reportedly draws inspiration from the life of professional ping pong player Marty Reisman.
THE PROS
  • Stellar performance by Timothée Chalamet
  • Exceptional directing style by Josh Safdie
  • Strong aesthetic and period production design
THE CONS
  • Narrative lacks a sincere heart
  • Telegraphed and predictable plot beats
  • Feels like a calculated awards-season project

Full Review


On the surface, Marty Supreme initially presents itself as a 1950s-era, Rocky-style underdog story set in the world of table tennis—or what most people simply call ping pong. If that concept elicits a bit of laughter, it’s no coincidence; the comedic undertone is entirely by design. Director Josh Safdie clearly understands that audiences aren't inherently clamoring for a ping pong movie, using the sport instead as a vehicle for a deeper narrative.

In reality, Marty Supreme is a character study that uses the game as a metaphor to explore the myth and tragedy of the American Dream—the fragile idea that hard work, talent, and perseverance alone can guarantee success. As the film’s events quickly demonstrate, while raw talent can open doors to fame and fortune, it eventually leads to a harsh dose of reality, followed by compromised morals and, ultimately, corruption. It is a tale as old as time; for those familiar with these narrative beats, it isn’t surprising to see things spiral out of control for the titular character.

However, the story itself isn't the main draw here. Marty Supreme serves primarily as a premier acting vehicle for Timothée Chalamet and a directing showcase for Safdie. Both come out of the project looking great, though I personally wish the story were more fulfilling. My attention frequently waned as "dramatic" moments and convenient resolutions were telegraphed by the obviously poor decisions of Marty and his inner circle.

Despite Safdie and Chalamet’s best efforts to generate intrigue, the film’s histrionics and blustering often lack a sense of sincere heart. As a cohesive story, the movie doesn’t quite click, feeling instead like a calculated awards-season project designed for the circuit. That said, the performances are stellar. Even though it is a showy role clearly crafted for accolades, Chalamet deserves the praise he has received, while Safdie cements his status as one of today’s most interesting and visually distinct cinematic voices. It is a bold effort, even if it feels a bit hollow at its core.


The Lucky13 Verdict
DOESN'T QUITE CLICK

While the performances and direction cement their status as top-tier talent, the story fails to remain as engaging as the people telling it.

★★★
Full review on LETTERBOXD

poster